Susan (McKay) Argentieri

HORNELL – Susan (McKay) Argentieri entered into eternal rest on Saturday (July 25, 2026), after a brief illness. She passed peacefully, surrounded by the love of her family and lifelong friends.

Susan was born on March 30, 1938. She was the daughter of Catherine Coston McKay and Gerald McKay. She was predeceased by her parents; brothers James and John McKay; and her beloved husband Walter Argentieri, to whom she was married for 56 years. They were married at St. Ann’s Church in Hornell, NY, on October 24, 1959.

She is survived by her children Lisa (Keith) Oley, Gina (Jim) Speedy, Toni (Rick) DeLettera, and Walter (Stephanie) Argentieri; her sister Kathy Zeiwfel; sisters‑in‑law Jean McKay, Doris (Robert) Kaplan, JoAnn Argentieri, and Peggy Creagan, ten grandchildren Amanda (Jamie) Gill, Vincent (Nicole) Oley, Nicholas (Bobbie Lou) Oley, Jimmy Speedy, Jacob (Breanna) Speedy, Catherine (David) Burke, Joseph DeLettera, Sam (Bethany) Argentieri, and Ava and Lia Argentieri; and seven great‑grandchildren George, Arthur, Evelyn and Zella Oley, Sadie Gill, Mason Argentieri, and Michael Speedy. Among those who will miss her most is her beloved best friend and neighbor of more than 50 years, Ann Hoeffner. Their enduring friendship was a source of love, laughter, and unwavering support throughout the years. Susan will also be remembered by her nieces and nephews, and her bonus grandchildren Colin, Conor and Caitlin.

A 1956 graduate of Hornell High School, Susan was a three‑year cheerleader and active on the Forensics team, where she hosted a Saturday radio show. During her senior year, she worked at Card’s Drug and Norbert’s Jeweler. She graduated from Erie Technical College in 1958 with a degree in Dental Hygiene alongside her longtime friend Carol Stevens (Butchie).

Susan worked for many years as a dental hygienist in the school system and in private practice, later semi‑retiring from Dr. Pearson’s office and working part time for Dr. Howewell. She also worked in catering at Alfred State College.

Active in her community, Susan was a longtime supporter of the Democratic Party, a proud and visible presence at election time. She served three years as President of the Hornell Alumni Association, where she held an honorary lifetime membership. Along with Matt DeGaetano and Alberta Dugo Cleveland, she helped start the Alumni Newsletter and served as one of its first editors. She was also a member of the Ladies of Sons of Italy. A member of Our Lady of the Valley Parish, Susan was a communicant of St. Ann’s Church in Hornell and was also a member of the Alpha Zeta Beta (AZB) Sorority.

Susan was known for her festive holiday decorations, warm family dinners always finished with a homemade dessert, and devoted presence at her grandchildren’s sports, chorus concerts, and school events. Grandchildren always left with a treat to take home, and they could count on holiday and birthday cards from their Uey — she often mailed gifts “just because.”

Susan’s family and friends will remember her warm hospitality, her deep love of family, and the traditions she lovingly carried on through the years. She found great joy in caring for her children and grandchildren, and she was always the first to offer to babysit whenever her children took a well-deserved vacation. Her beautiful gardens were a reflection of her nurturing spirit and brought her immense pride and happiness, just as they brought beauty to everyone who visited.

When God blessed us with you, it was the luckiest day of our lives. Your love, kindness, and unwavering devotion to your family will remain in our hearts forever.

The family would like to express their sincere appreciation to her caregivers that provided Susan with respectful and loving care during her illness.

Calling hours are 4-7 p.m. FRIDAY (July 31, 2026) at the Bishop-Johnson & Desanto Funeral Home, 285 Main St., Hornell. Relatives and friends are invited to join her family at St. Ann’s Church, 35 Erie Ave., Hornell, where a Mass of Christian Burial will be celebrated at 10 a.m. SATURDAY (Aug. 1, 2026) Private committal prayers and interment will follow at St. Mary’s Cemetery, Town of Fremont.

The livestream of Susan’s funeral mass and graveside service can be viewed here. 

In lieu of flowers, those wishing may contribute to the Hornell High School Alumni Association, P.O. Box 135, Hornell, NY 14843, or to St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, 501 St. Jude Place, Memphis, TN 38105 or CareFirst NY, 3805 Meads Creek Road, Painted Post, NY 14870. Envelopes for memorial contributions will be available at the funeral home and church.

The Bishop-Johnson & DeSanto Funeral Home is honored to assist Susan’s family with the arrangements.

Online condolences or remembrances of Susan are welcome below, or on the Facebook page of Bishop-Johnson & DeSanto Funeral Home.